|
|
|
|
ACUPUNCTURE
Alternative Treatments for Facial
Neuralgias
Disclaimer.
Acupuncture has long
been a somewhat controversial treatment. It is almost impossible to make controlled
double-blind studies with acupuncture, which means that acupuncture is often viewed with
skepticism by the medical community. However, acupuncture is a safe and riskless treatment
when done by a qualified professional, and it is not unheard of for qualified doctors to
suggest it for pain treatment. This is especially true when traditional medicine fails to
work.
For facial neuralgias
specifically, the evidence for or against acupuncture appears to be purely anecdotal. Some
have reported pain relief for long periods of time, others have had their pain worsen. (As
a personal observation, which may or may not be true, we would say that people with
classical TN seem to have very little success, whereas people with atypical TN report
success slightly more often). Anecdotal information also suggests that acupuncture has
been used for TN connected with multiple sclerosis, with some success; again, reliable
statistics cannot be found.
Sites with a very positive
attitude:
Acupuncture.com.
Quite New Age, but well written if you're into that sort of thing.
Sites with a roughly neutral attitude:
Some Thoughts on Efficacy
Does not make any fantastic claims about acupuncture, but does raise some interesting
questions about alternative treatments in general
Sites with a very critical attitude:
Skeptic's Dictionary -
Acupuncture
Skeptical approach to acupuncture
Skeptical Inquirer, Sept 1995.
Highly critical, sharply written.
Informal information
| Positive experiences |
 |
I Have
suffered with trigeminal Neuralgia for twenty years. In the beginning
it was hard to get a diagnosis. Then a dentist friend suggested it I
saw a neurologist who gave me a prescription for Tegretol which worked
for a while then I got a severe attack that put me in the pain center of
Massachusetts General Hospital. They suggested that I investigate
acupuncture. I have received acupuncture treatment once a week
together with 300mg of Tregretol (I had been taking 900mg) and I have
had only mild twinges for the last four years. Also pinching the soft
flesh between the index finger and thumb on the side of the attack
will relieve the pain. >I have been getting acupuncture for four
years. Used together with tegretol I am free of pain, except for
minimal twinges now and then, for four years. Competence of the acupuncturist
is fundamental. With acupuncture I need 300 mg without 900mg wasn't
holding it. |
 |
"Yes, I have tried
acupuncture and acupressure, which have offered some relief, but are not covered by the
insurance, so I cannot afford them. " "Julie" |
 |
"My acupuncture
treatments helped, because the pain level and intensity dropped over the ten days of
treatments." "Flash". |
 |
"I have been a
sufferer of TN for 20 years, and I am only 37 years old now, I have been through every
route of medical treatment known to Doctors. The ONLY relief I have found was from
acupuncture. I have read on the
treatments page that some have not had as much luck with it than I have. I do firmly
believe that it can be all to do with your own mind set and how your own acupuncturist
treats this disorder. I have now lived pain free for over 4 years, and live each day
to its fullest but without the pain." "Kim" |
| Negative experiences |
 |
"I tried acupuncture.
That just seemed to make the pain worse." "Winston". |
| Mixed experiences |
 |
"In March, I decided
to try acupuncture. It seemed to increase the episodes initially, but gradually the
episodes came less often...." [however, long-term outcome uncertain]. "LeVonne" |
| |
|
Acknowledgement.
Many of the links on this page were kindly contributed by Al Stone.
|